Fair screening
Fair tenant screening principles for Canadian landlords
Fair tenant screening means using the same written criteria for every applicant, deciding on facts about past tenancies, and staying inside your province’s human rights code and federal privacy law. In Manitoba and Saskatchewan that also means no application fee, a credit check only with the applicant’s consent, and a SIN that is always optional.
Updated · Provincial rules checked against the official sources linked on this page. General information, not legal advice.
Your name and email, then one tap in the email we send: your link is on the screen, ready to paste. No password today. Prefer a password? Create an account.
Principles
What are the principles of fair tenant screening?
Eight working rules. Each one makes the decision easier to explain to the applicant, and to anyone else who asks.
Use the same written criteria for everyone
Decide what you need before you list, and don't change the bar applicant by applicant.
Decide on tenancy facts, not labels
Dates, rent paid, notice given, the unit's condition. Not "bad tenant", rumours or impressions.
Stay off protected grounds
Leave anything tied to a human rights ground off the application, out of the reference call, and out of your notes.
Ask consent, and collect only what you need
Get consent before a credit check, keep a SIN optional, and view ID rather than copying it.
Treat a credit check as one signal
It shows borrowing, not how a tenancy went, so weigh it alongside the reference and the application.
Verify references, and record what you couldn't
Confirm the reference owns or manages the address. "Not verified" is an honest answer.
Let renters show proof behind their claims
An applicant can add documents that support specific things they wrote, such as a past lease or rent receipts. Weigh the claim the document supports.
Write down why
Which criteria the chosen applicant met, dated. If anyone asks, the file answers.
Human rights
Which human rights grounds apply to renting in each province?
These are the grounds as each Code lists them. Leave anything that touches them out of the application, the reference call and your notes. Elsewhere in Canada, check your province’s human rights commission.
British Columbia
The Human Rights Code (RSBC 1996, c. 210), s. 10, bars denying someone a tenancy, or setting its terms, because of a protected ground. Those grounds are:
- Indigenous identity
- Race
- Colour
- Ancestry
- Place of origin
- Religion
- Marital status
- Family status
- Physical or mental disability
- Sex
- Sexual orientation
- Gender identity or expression
- Age (19 and over)
- Lawful source of income
Space where the tenant would share sleeping, bathroom or cooking facilities with the person offering it, buildings where every unit is reserved for people 55 and over (for age and family status), and housing designed and reserved for people with disabilities are exempt. In practice, leave questions about children, pregnancy, religion, origin, relationship status or where someone’s income comes from off the application and out of your notes. Tenant screening in British Columbia.
Alberta
The Alberta Human Rights Act (RSA 2000, c. A-25.5), s. 5, bars denying someone a self-contained dwelling unit, or setting the terms of the tenancy, because of a protected ground. Those grounds are:
- Race
- Religious beliefs
- Colour
- Gender
- Gender identity
- Gender expression
- Physical disability
- Mental disability
- Age (18 and over)
- Ancestry
- Place of origin
- Marital status
- Source of income
- Family status
- Sexual orientation
The tenancy section covers self-contained dwelling units. Seniors-only housing where every unit is reserved for someone 55 or older is exempt from age and family status, as are minimum ages in condominiums, co-ops and mobile-home sites that existed before 2018 (they must convert by 2033). In practice, leave questions about children, origin, relationship status, religion or where someone’s income comes from off the application and out of your notes. Tenant screening in Alberta.
Saskatchewan
The Saskatchewan Human Rights Code, 2018 (S.S. 2018, c. S-24.2), s. 11, bars denying housing, or setting its terms, on a prohibited ground. Those grounds are:
- Religion
- Creed
- Marital status
- Family status (a parent–child relationship)
- Sex, including pregnancy
- Sexual orientation
- Disability
- Age (18 and over)
- Colour
- Ancestry
- Nationality
- Place of origin
- Race or perceived race
- Receipt of public assistance
- Gender identity
Exceptions: a unit in a building the owner or their family lives in, where the renter shares a bathroom or kitchen with them, is outside the Code’s housing rules. Sex alone may decide who rents in a building rented only to one sex, or in a two-unit building with a shared entrance where the owner or their family lives. Housing can be offered only to people 55 and over. In practice, leave questions about children, pregnancy, religion, origin, relationship status or assistance income off the application and out of your notes. Tenant screening in Saskatchewan.
Manitoba
The Human Rights Code (C.C.S.M. c. H175), s. 16, bars discrimination in renting unless there is bona fide and reasonable cause. The protected grounds, listed in s. 9(2), are:
- Ancestry, including colour and perceived race
- Nationality or national origin
- Ethnic background or origin
- Religion or creed
- Age
- Sex, including pregnancy
- Gender identity
- Gender expression
- Sexual orientation
- Marital or family status
- Source of income
- Political belief
- Physical or mental disability, including reliance on a service animal
- Social disadvantage
Owner-occupied duplexes and boarders in a private home are exempt. In practice, leave questions about children, pregnancy, religion, origin, relationship status or the source of someone’s income off the application and out of your notes. Tenant screening in Manitoba.
Ontario
The Human Rights Code (R.S.O. 1990, c. H.19), s. 2, gives everyone the right to equal treatment in occupying accommodation without discrimination. The protected grounds are:
- Race
- Ancestry
- Place of origin
- Colour
- Ethnic origin
- Citizenship
- Creed
- Sex
- Sexual orientation
- Gender identity
- Gender expression
- Age
- Marital status
- Family status
- Disability
- Receipt of public assistance
A unit where the tenant would share a kitchen or bathroom with the owner or the owner’s family is exempt, and a building where every other unit is restricted to one sex may stay so. O. Reg. 290/98 sets out how you may use credit references, rental history, credit checks, income information and guarantees; nothing in it lets you refuse someone on a protected ground. In practice, leave questions about children, origin, citizenship, relationship status, religion or where someone’s income comes from off the application and out of your notes. Tenant screening in Ontario.
Application fees
Can a landlord charge an application fee?
- British Columbia: Application fees are prohibited. Under the Residential Tenancy Act, s. 15, a landlord must not charge a person anything for accepting an application, processing it, investigating the applicant’s suitability, or accepting them as a tenant.
- Alberta: Application fees are not prohibited. The Residential Tenancies Act has no rule against them, and the government’s RTA Handbook says a landlord may charge one and an applicant who doesn’t want to pay it doesn’t have to apply. Disclose any fee when you take the application. A refundable fee counts as part of the security deposit; a non-refundable one is treated as rent.
- Saskatchewan: Application fees are prohibited. Under The Residential Tenancies Act, 2006, s. 23, a landlord can’t charge for accepting or processing an application, investigating an applicant’s suitability, or accepting someone as a tenant.
- Manitoba: Application fees are prohibited. Under The Residential Tenancies Act, s. 14(2), a landlord can’t charge to take, process or accept an application, or to check an applicant’s suitability.
- Ontario: Application fees are prohibited. Under the Residential Tenancies Act, 2006, s. 134, a landlord can’t collect a fee, premium, key money or any other amount from a prospective tenant, refundable or not. The only exempt payments are listed in O. Reg. 516/06, s. 17: a refundable key deposit at replacement cost, extra keys at cost, and NSF charges.
Privacy
What does privacy law require when you screen tenants?
In Manitoba and Saskatchewan the federal law, PIPEDA, covers landlords who handle personal information in the course of commercial activity; neither province has its own private-sector law.
- Consent before a credit check. You need the applicant’s consent to share their information with a credit bureau. Name, address and date of birth are the minimum.
- SIN optional. A SIN isn’t needed for a credit check. If you ask, make it clearly optional; refusing can’t be a reason to turn someone down.
- Only what the purpose needs. Collect nothing more than the decision requires.
- Informal checks count. Looking at social media or calling another landlord is collecting personal information too.
- View, don’t copy. ID and pay stubs can be viewed without keeping copies.
- Keep it briefly and safely. Hold the file no longer than you need it, and safeguard it.
Sources: Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada, Privacy in the landlord and tenant relationship and 10 privacy tips for the rental housing sector.
Optimized Rentals
What Optimized Rentals is, and isn’t
Optimized Rentals is Canadian landlord software that puts a tenancy on the record: condition reports, rent receipts and notices your tenant confirms by email, gathered into one printable tenancy record. Free for your first unit; tenants take part free.
What it does for screening
- One application link, so every applicant answers the same questions
- An applicant file with a completeness check and review notes
- Evidence support: documents the renter adds to back specific claims
- An ID check that compares the card with the application and deletes the photos; no Canadian photo ID is a fact, not a strike
- Rental history on Optimized Rentals told with every application; the renter chooses the details, and “not included” is neutral
What it is not
- Not a tenant blacklist or a public list of labels
- Not a credit bureau: it runs no credit checks
- Not a way to share a tenant’s details without them: a landlord they apply to is told a tenancy exists; the tenant chooses which details go, and only once they send
How we handle facts, privacy and tenants: our fairness approach.
FAQ
Fair tenant screening questions
What is fair tenant screening?
Fair tenant screening means applying the same written criteria to every applicant, deciding on facts about past tenancies, staying away from human rights grounds, and following privacy law: consent before a credit check, a SIN that is optional, and collecting only what the decision needs.
Can a landlord refuse a tenant because of their source of income?
In Manitoba, source of income is a protected ground under The Human Rights Code. In Saskatchewan, receipt of public assistance is a protected ground under The Saskatchewan Human Rights Code, 2018. The question to ask is whether the rent can be paid, not where the money comes from.
Can a landlord ask for a SIN?
Only as a clearly optional field. Canada's privacy commissioner says a SIN isn't needed for a credit check, and refusing to give one can't be a reason to turn someone down.
Are tenant blacklists fair?
No. A list of labels or revenge-style claims isn't fair screening, and Optimized Rentals is not one. Fair screening uses facts the applicant can see and answer, such as a previous landlord's account of dates, rent and notice.
Does fair screening mean ignoring risk?
No. You can still check income, references and, with consent, credit. The difference is that you judge every applicant on the same relevant criteria and record why.
Related guides
More screening guides
The six steps and a Manitoba and Saskatchewan comparison.
Printable screening checklistTick boxes for every part of the applicant file.
What a rental application should askThe fields to include and the questions to leave off.
Landlord reference checkQuestions to ask and how to verify the reference.
Facts, not labelsWhy fair screening needs facts the applicant can answer.
Why blacklists are the wrong modelWhat goes wrong with lists of labels.
Next step
Start with the same application for everyone
One link for your listing; every applicant answers the same questions and lands in their own file. Free for your first unit, no card.