Fairness
Fairness: what Optimized Rentals does and doesn't do
Optimized Rentals is not a tenant blacklist or a rating site. It keeps a dated record of one tenancy that the landlord and the tenant both see and confirm. A landlord the tenant applies to here is told the tenancy exists; the tenant chooses which details go with it.
Updated
Boundaries
What does Optimized Rentals not do?
These limits keep any one record or signal from claiming more than it shows.
Optimized Rentals does not:
- publish ratings, reviews or lists of tenants or landlords
- run a public tenant blacklist
- label people as good or bad tenants
- run credit checks
- share a tenancy's details with a next landlord unless the tenant includes them; the landlord is told the tenancy exists
- show a tenant's private documents to a landlord without the tenant's approval
- keep ID images, licence numbers or addresses
- let a landlord add a past tenancy without a document, or without telling the former tenant
- treat a missing reference or confirmation as negative evidence
- treat a renter's explanation as independent proof
- treat a document as authentic just because it was uploaded
- promise how a tenancy or a dispute will turn out, or give legal advice
Is Optimized Rentals a tenant blacklist?
No. There is no public list of tenants and no ratings or reviews. A tenancy record belongs to the tenancy it came from: the landlord and the tenant in that tenancy see it. A landlord the tenant applies to on Optimized Rentals is told it exists for 5 years after it ends; the tenant chooses which details go, and a detail left out reads "on file, not included". What a landlord learns about past tenancies.
Blacklists and review sites spread one side's account with no way to answer it. A dated record that both sides can see, with any difference kept in the tenant's own words, is harder to dispute and fairer to both. More on why tenant blacklists are the wrong model.
Side by side
How is this different from a tenant list?
Landlord groups sometimes keep a list: names, and what each landlord says happened. It spreads fast, the tenant rarely knows, and nothing on it has to be true. A tenancy record does the one job the list was for, telling the next landlord, and leaves out everything that gets a list taken down.
| Point of difference | A tenant list | A tenancy record here |
|---|---|---|
| Who can see it | Anyone in the group, and anyone they screenshot it for. | The landlord and the tenant of that tenancy. A landlord the tenant applies to here is told it exists. It is never published and never in a search. |
| What it says | A name and one side's account of what happened. | Dates, amounts and documents: the lease, the receipts, the condition reports, an order. There is no field for an opinion, a warning or a label. |
| Does the tenant know? | Usually not, until someone tells them. | Always. They are told by email and text, see every document and every amount, and answer with fixed choices that are kept beside the landlord's. |
| What backs it up | Nothing has to. | A tenancy added after it ended needs a document naming the tenant at that street before it follows them. The landlord attests that what they entered is true and the documents are true copies. |
| Who decides what a next landlord reads | Whoever posted. | The tenant picks which details go with their application. A detail left out reads "on file, not included", so the next landlord knows it is there and that it was left out. |
| How long it lasts | As long as the screenshots do. | A landlord the tenant applies to is told for 5 years after the tenancy ends. An older tenancy goes only if the tenant includes it. |
Either way the tenancy ends up on the record. If the tenant already left, put that tenancy on the record now with the lease or an order as proof, before you have an account. If the tenant is living there now, run the tenancy here and the record builds itself as rent, reports and notices are confirmed. What a next landlord is told is on what a landlord learns about past tenancies.
Defamation and privacy
What protects a landlord who puts a tenancy on the record?
The question landlords ask before they record anything is whether it comes back on them. Six things in the design answer it. They describe what the product does and doesn't do; none of them is legal advice.
There is nowhere to write an opinion
A defamation claim starts with a statement about a person: a warning, a label, a story. The record has none, because there is no field for one. Every line a next landlord reads is a date, an amount or a status, never a comment.
The tenant is told and answers
A complaint about a one-sided record is hard to bring against one both sides can see. The former tenant gets the whole file, documents included, and their answer sits beside yours: a disputed date reads as under dispute, and "that wasn't me" replaces the details.
A document comes first
A tenancy added after it ended follows the tenant only once a document shows their name and the street, or they answer "that was me". The document is compared with what you entered, and you attest that what you entered is true and the documents are true copies.
Nothing is published
The record is not on a page anyone can open, not in a search, and not sent to a landlord the tenant has not applied to. What a next landlord learns, they learn because the tenant sent them an application.
It is the file you already keep
Landlords keep leases, ledgers, condition reports and orders. The record is that file, each entry dated the day it went on the record, with the tenant's answers kept with it. It adds nothing about the person that the paper does not say.
The same design protects the tenant
No label, no rating, no comment, a copy of their own for free, and the last word on which details go with their application. That is what makes the record one a next landlord can trust, and a warning in a group is not.
What you record about your own tenancies is yours to record truthfully, and the attestation when you finish says so. If you're unsure whether to record a particular tenancy, ask a lawyer or your provincial tenancy office. What each side sees is on the privacy page.
The tenancy record
How is the tenancy record fair to both sides?
One record, both sides
The landlord and the tenant see the same dated record. Condition reports are confirmed, added to or marked with a difference item by item, and rent receipts read "Confirmed by both" only when both have answered.
A difference stays on the record
When a tenant notes a difference, their words and photos are kept beside the landlord's. Neither side overwrites the other.
The tenant's own copy, free
Tenants never pay. With a free tenant account, the tenant can open and print their own copy of the tenancy record.
The tenant decides which details go
When a tenancy ends, the file is kept. A landlord the tenant applies to on Optimized Rentals is told it exists for 5 years after it ends; which details go with it is the tenant's choice, and nothing goes until they send.
Applications
How are rental applicants treated?
- Results are per claim (an address, a rent amount, tenancy dates), never a score for the person.
- A reference who never answers shows as no confirmation received, which is neutral.
- Renters can correct a misread detail and add context for a difference.
- A renter's documents stay private unless the renter approves a landlord's request to open one.
Evidence support, a reference's confirmation and a renter's explanation are kept apart: see how the three compare. For the landlord's side of fair screening, including human rights grounds, see fair tenant screening principles.