Landlord reference checks

Landlord reference check: questions to ask and how to verify the reference

A landlord reference check is a call to a previous landlord to confirm what the applicant told you: the address, the dates, the rent, and how the tenancy ended. First confirm the person you’re calling really owns or manages that address, then ask factual questions and write down the answers, including what they couldn’t confirm. Have the applicant’s consent on file before you call.

Updated

Your name and email, then one tap in the email we send: your link is on the screen, ready to paste. No password today. Prefer a password? Create an account.

See what the record looks like Four minutes, nothing to type, no account.
See it happen

Who to call

Why call a previous landlord, not only the current one?

1
A current landlord has a stake

They may want the tenant to move on. A past landlord has nothing to gain from the answer, and can tell you how the tenancy ended.

2
The number may not be the landlord’s

A contact supplied by the applicant can be a friend or relative. Note where every number came from.

3
Vague answers can’t be checked

“Great tenant” or “difficult” tells you little. Dates, rent, notice and deposit facts can be compared with the application.

A reference is one part of the file, alongside the application, ID and income. Why it can’t carry the decision alone: why landlord references are not enough.

Already on the record

What if the previous tenancy was on Optimized Rentals?

When a renter applies to you on Optimized Rentals, you're told every tenancy on the platform tied to them from the last 5 years: the city, the years, how it was tied to them, and which details are on file. The renter chooses which details go, and you see how many they included.

You still call the reference for anything the record doesn't show. What a landlord learns about past tenancies.

Before you ask

How do you verify the reference is really the landlord?

These are common landlord practices, not legal requirements. The point is to know who you are talking to before their answers count.

1
Note where the contact came from

The applicant, a company website, or a public record. A number the applicant gave you is a starting point, not proof.

2
Check who owns the address

Many landlords look up the owner through municipal property tax or assessment records, or a provincial land titles search, and compare the name with the reference.

3
Call a company on its own number

If a property manager runs the building, call the main number on the company’s website and ask for the person, rather than dialling the number supplied.

4
Ask open questions first

“Which address did they rent?” before you say what the applicant told you. Someone who has to guess the address, the rent or the dates is not confirming anything.

5
Record “not verified” when you can’t verify

If dates or addresses don’t match, write down the gap and ask the applicant about it, instead of forcing the reference into a yes or no.

Printable template

What should you ask a previous landlord?

One copy per reference. Ask in this order: identity and dates first, opinions last.

Before the call

  • Applicant name
    ______________________________
  • Address and unit they say they rented
    ______________________________
  • Reference name and role (owner, property manager, other)
    ______________________________
  • Where the contact came from (applicant, company website, public record)
    ______________________________
  • Owner or manager confirmed? How?
    ______________________________
  • Applicant's consent on file
    ______________________________
  • Date and time of the call
    ______________________________
1
What address did the applicant rent from you, and which unit?

Ask it open. If they can't name the address, stop and note it.

Answer: ______________________________________________

2
Do you own the property, or manage it? For whom?

Compare the answer with what you found when you checked ownership.

Answer: ______________________________________________

3
When did the tenancy start and end?

Compare with the dates on the application.

Answer: ______________________________________________

4
What was the monthly rent, and was it paid on time?

Ask whether any balance was owing when they left.

Answer: ______________________________________________

5
Did they give written notice before moving out?

Note how much notice, if they know.

Answer: ______________________________________________

6
Apart from normal wear, how was the unit left? Did you keep any of the deposit, and why?

A deposit claim is a fact; "messy" is an opinion.

Answer: ______________________________________________

7
Did you serve any notices during the tenancy, such as for unpaid rent?

Write down what notice, and roughly when.

Answer: ______________________________________________

8
How did they handle repair requests and notices to enter?

Ask for examples, not adjectives.

Answer: ______________________________________________

9
Would you rent to them again? What makes you say that?

The reason matters more than the yes or no.

Answer: ______________________________________________

10
Is there anything I should confirm with someone else?

Note any other source they point you to.

Answer: ______________________________________________

After the call

  • What the reference confirmed, in their words where it matters
  • What didn't match the application
  • What they couldn't or wouldn't confirm
  • Follow-up needed, and from whom
  • Your initials and the date

Boundaries

What not to ask or record

The same limits apply to the reference as to the application.

  • Questions tied to a human rights ground: family status, pregnancy, religion, disability, origin, age, or source of income (in Saskatchewan, receipt of public assistance). Full lists for British Columbia, Alberta, Saskatchewan, Manitoba and Ontario.
  • Rumours, labels and personal opinions that say nothing about the tenancy.
  • More about the applicant than the reference needs to hear. Confirm facts; don’t share the application.
  • Passing on what a reference told you to anyone else.

Calling another landlord counts as collecting personal information under the federal privacy commissioner’s guidance (Privacy in the landlord and tenant relationship), so keep notes to what the decision needs. More in fair tenant screening principles.

FAQ

Landlord reference check questions

What is a landlord reference check?

A landlord reference check is a call to an applicant's previous landlord to confirm the address, tenancy dates, rent, and how the tenancy ended. It works only if you first confirm the person you reach really owns or manages that address.

What questions should I ask a landlord reference?

Ask factual questions the landlord can answer from the tenancy: the address and unit, whether they own or manage it, the start and end dates, the rent and whether it was paid on time, notice given, the unit's condition at move-out, any deposit kept, and whether they would rent to the applicant again and why.

How can I tell if a landlord reference is fake?

Check who owns the property, for example through municipal property tax or land titles records, or call a management company on the number from its own website. Ask open questions, such as which address the applicant rented, before you share what the applicant told you. A reference who can't name the address, the rent or the dates should be noted as not verified.

Do I need the applicant's permission to call their previous landlord?

Canada's privacy commissioner says informal checks such as calling another landlord are a collection of personal information. The simplest way to cover it is a consent line on the rental application.

What should I avoid asking a landlord reference?

Anything tied to a human rights ground, such as family status, religion, disability, origin, age, or source of income or public assistance, plus rumours, labels and personal opinions that say nothing about the tenancy.

How should I record a reference check?

Write down the date, who you reached and how you confirmed their role, what they confirmed, what didn't match the application, what they couldn't confirm, and any follow-up. Keep it with the applicant file only as long as you need it.

Next step

Get the landlord contacts up front

Send one application link: every applicant lists their past addresses with dates, each landlord’s contact details, and whether you may contact them, in their own file. Free for your first unit, no card.