Printable checklist

Tenant screening checklist for landlords

A tenant screening file should hold the same things for every applicant: the application, the ID and income you checked, at least one previous-landlord reference, a credit report only if the applicant consented, and a note of why you decided. Print this checklist and tick the boxes for each applicant; anything left unticked is what to follow up before you sign.

Updated · Provincial rules checked against the official sources linked on this page. General information, not legal advice.

Email me my free application link

Your name and email, then one tap in the email we send: your link is on the screen, ready to paste. No password today. Prefer a password? Create an account.

Watch an application arrive and get chosen Four minutes, nothing to type, no account.
See it happen

One copy per applicant

What goes in a tenant screening file?

Applicant: ______________________ · Unit: ______________ · Date: __________

1. Before you list

  • Screening criteria written down (income, references, move-in date) and the same for everyone
  • One application form for every adult applicant
  • No application fee: it is prohibited in British Columbia, Saskatchewan, Manitoba and Ontario (Alberta allows one, disclosed up front)
  • Consent wording ready for reference calls and any credit check

2. The application

  • Full name, phone and email
  • Current and past addresses, with move-in and move-out dates
  • Landlord name and contact for each past address
  • Employer, role, and income
  • Who will live in the unit, and any pets
  • Requested move-in date
  • Signed consent for the checks you will run
  • Anything missing or unclear, noted with the date you asked for it

3. ID and income

  • Photo ID viewed, or ID details matched on Optimized Rentals (images deleted); name matches the application, date noted, no copy needed
  • Proof of income viewed: pay stubs, an employment letter, or a benefits statement
  • Rent compared with income using the criteria you wrote down
  • Source of income not used as a reason to refuse (a protected ground in British Columbia, Alberta, Manitoba and Ontario; receipt of public assistance is in Saskatchewan)

4. References

  • A previous landlord reached, not only the current one
  • Confirmed the reference owns or manages that address
  • Tenancy dates and rent match the application
  • Answers on rent, notice and move-out condition written down in facts
  • Gaps or mismatches noted rather than forced into a yes or no
  • Rental history on Optimized Rentals read; details the applicant included noted
  • Employer confirmed, if your criteria need it

5. Credit check (only if you use one)

  • Consent to share details with a credit bureau, in writing
  • Only what the bureau needs shared (name, address, date of birth); SIN optional
  • A refused SIN not counted against the applicant
  • Report kept with the file and what it showed noted

6. The decision

  • Which criteria the chosen applicant met
  • Why other applicants weren't chosen, in facts
  • Date of the decision, and date each applicant was told
  • File kept only as long as you need it, stored safely

7. Before you hand over keys

  • Lease signed, tenant has a copy
  • Deposit within the cap (British Columbia and Manitoba: half a month's rent; Alberta and Saskatchewan: one month, Saskatchewan no more than half at signing; Ontario: no damage deposit, only a rent deposit for the last month)
  • Written receipt for the deposit
  • Move-in condition report done together, with dated photos, tenant has a copy

Keep out of the file

  • Anything about a protected ground: children, pregnancy, religion, origin, relationship status, disability
  • Rumours, labels and opinions unrelated to the tenancy
  • Social media screenshots that aren't about the rental
  • Copies of ID or a SIN you don't need

Privacy points follow the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada’s Privacy in the landlord and tenant relationship. Deposit and fee rules: The Residential Tenancies Act (Manitoba) and The Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 (Saskatchewan).

Why it matters

Why keep a screening file at all?

Because it lets you show that every applicant went through the same steps, and why you chose who you chose. If someone asks, a dated file with the criteria you set beats a memory of phone calls and texts.

The steps behind each box are in the Canadian tenant screening guide; the questions to ask a previous landlord are on the reference check template; and the fields for the form are in what a rental application should ask.

FAQ

Tenant screening file questions

What should a tenant screening file include?

The application, a note of the ID and income you viewed, at least one previous-landlord reference with what they confirmed, a credit report only if the applicant consented, and a short record of why you chose the applicant you chose.

Can a landlord charge an application fee?

Not in British Columbia (Residential Tenancy Act, s. 15), Saskatchewan (Residential Tenancies Act, 2006, s. 23), Manitoba (Residential Tenancies Act, s. 14(2)) or Ontario (Residential Tenancies Act, 2006, s. 134). Alberta allows one if you disclose it when you take the application. Elsewhere, check your residential tenancy office.

Do I need the applicant's SIN for a credit check?

No. Canada's privacy commissioner says a SIN isn't needed for a credit check. If you ask for one it must be clearly optional, and refusing to give it can't be a reason to turn someone down.

Should I keep copies of ID and pay stubs?

You don't have to. ID and pay stubs can be viewed without keeping copies. Note what you saw and the date, and keep the rest of the file only as long as you need it.

Does a credit check replace a landlord reference?

No. A credit report shows borrowing, not how a tenancy went. It usually doesn't show rent paid to a private landlord, move-out condition, or whether the lease was completed. A previous-landlord reference covers that.

Next step

Let the application fill in half the checklist

Send one application link and every applicant answers the same questions, in their own file. Free for your first unit, no card.