Tenant Screening

How to Check a Tenant's ID Without Keeping a Copy

A photocopy of a tenant's driver's licence is a liability you hold for years. What you actually need is to know the name and date of birth on the card match the application. Here is how to get that without keeping the card.

5 min read
Share LinkedIn X Email

Most landlords check ID the way they were taught: ask for the driver's licence, photocopy it or snap a photo, and file it with the application. It feels thorough. It also leaves you holding a licence number, a home address and someone's photo for as long as the file exists, and you are responsible for all of it. This post covers what you actually need from an ID, why keeping the copy is the wrong habit, and how the ID check on Optimized Rentals gets you the answer without the copy.

Why is a photocopy of a tenant's ID a problem?

Privacy law in Canada expects you to collect only the personal information you need for a stated purpose, to protect what you keep, and to get rid of it when the purpose is done. The Office of the Privacy Commissioner's guidance on privacy in the landlord and tenant relationship sets that out for landlords. A copy of a driver's licence carries more than you need: the licence number, the address, the signature and the photo. If that copy is lost, stolen or shared, the harm lands on your tenant and the responsibility lands on you.

There is a practical cost too. A folder of ID copies has to be stored somewhere safe, kept away from anyone who does not need it, and shredded at the right time. Most small landlords do none of those things, not from carelessness but because the folder was never the point. The point was to know who you were dealing with.

What do you actually need from the ID?

Three things. That the name on the card is the name on the application. That the date of birth on the card is the one on the application. That the card is current. That is what an ID check is for: to tie the application to a real document about a real person. You do not need the licence number for that, you do not need the address, and you do not need to keep the picture.

Looking at the card and handing it back has always been the better practice. The difficulty was that a glance leaves no record, so when the application is reviewed a week later, nobody can say what was checked. The product is built to fix that gap without reintroducing the copy.

How does the ID check on Optimized Rentals work?

Every applicant confirms their email and mobile by code before they can send an application. Most confirm their ID once, from their own application page: they photograph the front of their driver's licence or provincial photo ID and the barcode on the back. Software reads the name, date of birth and expiry from the card, compares them with the application, and deletes the photos. You see whether it matches, never the photos, and you can ask for it on any request or application link with Ask for their ID.

The applicant does it on their phone in under a minute, or from a computer with a hand-off to their phone. The result reads as a fact about the check: "ID details match", or what differed. It is never a badge on the person.

What is kept, and what never is?

We keep the confirmed name, date of birth, ID type, issuer and expiry, and that it was checked. Never the images, the licence number or the address. The review copy of the photos exists only for minutes while the check is read, and a check that never became part of a tenancy is removed after a set period, stated on the privacy page. The applicant can remove their own check at any time, and it goes out of date if their name, date of birth or ID changes.

That is the whole trade. You get the answer you were after, recorded and dated. You hold nothing you would have to protect.

What if an applicant has no Canadian photo ID?

An applicant without Canadian photo ID says so, and the application still goes through; you see that instead of a result. Newcomers, people between licences and people who never drove are not a smaller pool of good tenants, and the check is built so that it never blocks an application. Treat "No Canadian photo ID" as what it is: an answer, not a strike.

Does the check prove the ID is genuine?

No, and nothing on a phone screen does. The software reads the name, date of birth and expiry and compares them with the application. It does not tell you that a card is real, and it does not detect a forgery. What it tells you is that the document the applicant held up carries the same details they typed, and that the card has not expired. That is the same thing a careful glance at the counter told you, now dated and attached to the application.

What if you meet them in person?

If you have met the applicant with their card in hand, note it with Confirm in person on their application. It records that you, on that date, confirmed the person against their ID. It is your note, so it carries exactly as much weight as you do, and it is still the strongest confirmation on the platform: a person who met the person.

Why does every tenancy ask for ID?

Every tenancy on Optimized Rentals asks each tenant to confirm their ID, and it is not a setting you turn on or off. It is there for your protection: the person on the tenancy is the person on the ID, the record stays tied to that person for as long as it exists, and you never hold a copy of anyone's card. They do it from their phone in under a minute, with a reminder if they have not yet, and nothing on the tenancy waits for it; you see "Identity confirmed", never the photos. A renter who already did the check for an application they sent you does not do it again.

The reason is the record itself. A tenancy record is only worth something if it is about a known person. Rent receipts, condition reports and the deposit all tie to the tenant who confirmed, so when a dispute comes up a year later, nobody has to argue about who the tenant was.

Where does this sit in your screening file?

ID is one line in a screening file, next to the application, income, references and rental history. Our screening file checklist puts it in order, and the tenant ID check page covers what the check reads, what it keeps and what you see, in more detail than this post.

Watch an application arrive and get chosen Four minutes, nothing to type, no account.
See it happen

Put the guide into practice

Build a rental record around facts.

Optimized Rentals is Canadian landlord software that puts a tenancy on the record: condition reports, rent receipts and notices your tenant confirms by email, gathered into one printable tenancy record. Free for your first unit; tenants take part free.